The Successor Trustee Trap: When an Estate Plan Changes Corporate Control
Your client transfers controlling shares of a private corporation to an alter ego trust. The trust deed names a successor trustee to take over on incapacity or death. Years later, that person steps in exactly as planned.
There is no sale and no change to the corporation’s business. Yet the trustee replacement may trigger an acquisition of control—and put the corporation’s tax attributes at risk.
That is the planning issue addressed in CRA technical interpretation 2026-1089221C6 (Question 8 at the June 2, 2026 STEP CRA Roundtable).
A routine succession with a corporate tax consequence
Alter ego trusts and joint partner trusts are commonly used as will substitutes. The settlor often acts as trustee initially, with a family member, trusted adviser or independent trust company designated to take over later.
Where the trust holds controlling shares, that succession requires more than an administrative update.
In the interpretation, the CRA reiterates its longstanding view that trustees hold legal title to the shares and the associated voting rights. Where there are multiple trustees, the CRA generally presumes that they act as a group controlling the corporation, unless the evidence establishes otherwise.
A change in trustees can therefore change who controls the corporation, even though the shares remain trust property.
The relieving rule has a narrow doorway
Paragraph 256(7)(i) of the Income Tax Act can prevent an acquisition of control arising solely from a trustee replacement. Both conditions must be satisfied:
The replacement must not form part of a series that includes a change in beneficial ownership of the trust property.
No income or capital distribution, at or after the replacement, in respect of a trust interest may depend on anyone exercising—or failing to exercise—a discretionary power.
The second condition is particularly significant for alter ego and joint partner trusts.
The capital encroachment problem
These trusts commonly authorize trustees to encroach on capital for the lifetime beneficiary. That flexibility may be important to the estate plan, but it can also prevent access to paragraph 256(7)(i).
The CRA notes that whether a power is discretionary depends on the trust deed and the facts. However, it generally considers a power to encroach on capital or income to be a discretionary authority.
What matters is the existence and effect of the power under the deed. Advisers should not assume that relief applies simply because the trustees have never exercised it.
If paragraph 256(7)(i) is unavailable, the identity of the successor trustee becomes critical.
Does choosing a family member solve the problem?
Assuming paragraph 256(7)(i) does not apply, the CRA’s general conclusions in the scenarios presented are:
Unrelated individual: an acquisition of control generally occurs.
Independent trust company: an acquisition of control generally occurs.
Related individual: paragraph 256(7)(a) may provide relief, depending on the applicable conditions.
The related-person exception requires careful attention. Clause 256(7)(a)(i)(A) addresses an acquisition of shares from a person to whom the acquirer was related immediately before the acquisition. Clause 256(7)(a)(i)(B) separately addresses an acquirer related to the particular corporation immediately before the acquisition.
Describing the replacement trustee as “related to the settlor” is therefore not a complete statutory analysis. Identify the relevant persons, their capacities and the precise relieving provision before concluding that the replacement is protected.
Why the corporation’s losses matter
For a corporation, an acquisition of control is a loss restriction event under paragraph 251.2(2)(a). The consequences can include a deemed taxation year-end, restrictions on the use of non-capital losses and the loss of access to certain other tax attributes.
Not every loss automatically disappears—the consequences depend on the attribute and the applicable rules. Nevertheless, a trustee succession can materially affect the value and availability of those attributes.
Review the succession plan before it takes effect
Where a trust holds controlling shares, the review should connect the trust deed with the corporation’s tax position:
Examine capital encroachment and other distribution powers.
Test both conditions in paragraph 256(7)(i).
Identify who controls the corporation before and after the replacement.
Consider whether paragraph 256(7)(a) applies to the actual succession.
Assess the corporation’s losses and other affected tax attributes.
An independent trustee may be the right choice for the family’s estate plan. That choice should be made with a clear understanding of the corporate tax consequences.
A successor trustee clause is also a corporate tax planning provision. Review it with the same care as the original transfer of shares to the trust.
Source note: This article is based on a summary of CRA technical interpretation 2026-1089221C6 (STEP CRA Roundtable, Question 8, June 2, 2026, Olivier Bergeron), which refers to 2022-0928191C6. The interpretation notes that it may not reflect the CRA’s current position. Confirm the relevant statutory provisions against the facts before implementation.
Statutory reference: Income Tax Act, section 256.