The Dividend Trap That Can Cost Your Client the Capital Gains Deduction
Your client is selling common shares in the family business. You’ve confirmed that the shares are qualified small business corporation shares and that your client has room to claim the lifetime capital gains exemption. Then you open the minute book. A parent still owns preferred shares from an estate freeze ten years ago, and the company has never paid a dividend on them.
Could that dividend history affect your client’s claim? It can. Subsection 110.6(8) of the Income Tax Act can deny the deduction on the common-share gain if a significant part of that gain arose because the company paid insufficient dividends on a non-prescribed share. The parent’s preferred shares are a good place to start the review. (Income Tax Act, subsections 110.6(8) and (9))
Start with the shares, then look at the dividends
Consider a business with one class of ordinary common shares. The founder reinvests profits for fifteen years and realizes the return on a sale. If those shares were prescribed throughout, and the gain cannot be traced to missed dividends on any other non-prescribed share, subsection 110.6(8) leaves the deduction intact. There is no annual dividend target for those common shares.
Whether a share is prescribed turns on its terms and the agreements governing it. Under Regulation 6205(1), look for a ceiling or floor on dividends or liquidation proceeds, including a limit buried in a formula. Check conversion rights, redemption or retraction rights, obligations to reduce paid-up capital, and arrangements that promise a return of capital, protect the holder against loss or guarantee earnings. The word “common” on the share certificate settles none of these questions. (Income Tax Regulations, subsection 6205(1))
Read the amendments as well as the original articles. Under paragraph 6205(4)(e), changing a share’s terms, amending an agreement about it or entering into a new agreement about it can trigger a deemed new issue. A buy-sell provision signed years after incorporation can therefore change the analysis. Paragraph 6205(4)(d) provides relief for specified rights in certain written private-company shareholder agreements, subject to voting-ownership and anti-avoidance conditions. Employee buybacks have their own conditions under paragraph 6205(4)(f), including how the purchase price is determined. (Income Tax Regulations, subsection 6205(4))
Revisit the estate freeze
Return to the parent’s preferred shares. Their fixed redemption value is a reason to pull the freeze documents. Paragraph 6205(2)(a) provides a separate route to prescribed status. In a conventional parent-child freeze, the documents should establish who received the preferred shares, that the main purpose was to direct future appreciation to other shares that independently qualified as prescribed when issued, and who owned those growth shares when the preferred shares were issued or the arrangement ended.
If a family trust subscribed for the growth shares, read the beneficiary clause. A class of beneficiaries broad enough to include a niece or nephew deserves particular attention. If an arm’s-length business partner also received growth shares, determine whether that person fits a permitted category. Employees of the corporation, or of a corporation it controls, can qualify—including alongside eligible family shareholders. For a refreeze, trace the growth shares issued under each arrangement. For an amalgamation, compare the terms and value of the replacement shares with those surrendered. (Income Tax Regulations, paragraphs 6205(2)(a) and (4)(c))
What if the preferred shares fail the test?
Now the dividend history matters. Subsection 110.6(9) looks to the annual dividend return that a knowledgeable, prudent investor buying at issue would have expected under prescribed assumptions. These include timely dividends, generally consistent payments and an eventual sale for the original issue price. The provision expressly distinguishes the first year after issue.
Suppose the statutory benchmark for a particular year is 5%. A 4% dividend yield falls below the 4.5% threshold (90% of the benchmark), which identifies a shortfall. The remaining question is how much of your client’s common-share gain can reasonably be attributed to it.
The business may have gained value by opening profitable locations or winning a long-term contract. The unpaid preferred dividends may also have left additional cash in the company for the common shareholders. Use the financial statements, dividend records and valuation evidence to distinguish those sources of growth. The Act sets no numerical threshold for a “significant part.” If that test is met, the client loses the deduction for the entire affected gain, even where the dividend shortfall explains only part of it. (Income Tax Act, subsections 110.6(8) and (9))
Before a sale or crystallization
Reconstruct the share history. Identify each relevant class, its holders, the issue dates, and any subsequent amendments, exchanges or buy-sell agreements.
Record why each class qualifies. For freeze shares, identify the original holder, the growth shareholders and any trust beneficiaries at the relevant time.
Quantify any exposure. For each non-prescribed share, compare the actual dividends with the statutory benchmark year by year, and document what drove the gain on the property being sold.
On a sale file, ask for the freeze binder when you request the share register. Ten years without a preferred dividend may be easy to explain. The binder tells you whether you need to explain it at all.
This article provides general information about Canadian income tax. Its application to a particular transaction depends on the share terms, agreements and surrounding facts.